Skip to main content
Okay so I have to be upfront about something. A few weeks ago I knew basically nothing about trading. Like, I’d heard terms like “technical analysis” and “chart patterns” thrown around on social media, but my actual knowledge was basically zero. Someone in a Discord server I’m in mentioned Stocks with Josh, and I figured, why not? I’d been wanting to learn this stuff for months and kept putting it off. Short answer: if you’re a beginner trying to figure out whether this is worth your time, yes. It is. Especially if you actually want to learn, not just copy trades without understanding them. Here’s the longer, more honest version of how it went. START YOUR OWN JOURNEY and see what day one actually looks like

Day One: I Logged In Knowing Absolutely Nothing

First thing I did was look at what was actually available. There are two main offerings on Whop. The Chart Goat U product runs 100permonth∗∗,andthe∗∗SWJTraderTier∗∗ispricedat∗∗100 per month**, and the **SWJ Trader Tier** is priced at **60 per week. I stared at those numbers for a while. For a beginner who’d never spent money on trading education, that felt significant. But I kept reading. Chart Goat U is positioned specifically for people learning stock and crypto trading with hands-on guidance and simple strategies. That bullet point was written for me. I also noticed Whop sometimes shows a welcome discount popup when you first visit, so worth checking whether that’s active when you look. The SWJ Trader Tier looked like the more community-focused option: Discord access, weekly live sessions, priority chart requests, meet-and-greets. It has 737 members at the time I’m writing this. Chart Goat U had around 98 members, which actually made me think it might feel more focused. I went with a look at both. The community around stocks with josh on the Whop page felt genuinely active. That was the first thing that made me exhale a little.

The First Few Days: More Confusion Than I Expected

Here’s where I’ll be honest. Walking in with zero background in trading, there was a real learning curve. I kept seeing terms like “key levels” (which, I found out, basically means specific price points on a chart where buying or selling pressure has historically been strong), “charting,” and “price action” everywhere. I had about six tabs open at any given time trying to make sense of it. The good news: the community didn’t feel hostile to questions. One review I came across described how someone named Money Mike, also called SpyLord on the team, “explains things in such a clear, practical way that a lot of stuff finally clicked.” That matched my experience watching some of the content. The explanations weren’t talking down to beginners, but they also weren’t assuming you already knew what a Fibonacci retracement was (I did not). I think most people new to this would hit the same initial wall I did. It’s not that the material is unclear. It’s that trading terminology is genuinely a different language, and there’s a moment early on where you have to trust the process before things start making sense.

What I Was Actually Looking At (And What It Took to Figure It Out)

The product description mentions trade alerts, analysis, educational content on stocks and crypto, and bots. “Bots” threw me off at first. I assumed that meant some kind of automated trading, and I got nervous. Turns out the way it’s framed in the Chart Goat U experience, it’s more about having tools that flag opportunities rather than auto-trading without your knowledge. Still learning the specifics, but that context helped. The priority chart requests feature inside the Trader Tier was one of the things I kept coming back to. Basically, you can submit a specific stock or crypto chart and get analysis on it. For a beginner who has no idea how to read a chart themselves yet, having someone break down exactly what they’re seeing on something you’re actually watching in your own account is incredibly useful. It’s not hypothetical. It’s your ticker, your question. I also noticed that the educational content covers both stocks and crypto. That breadth was something I appreciated. A lot of resources I’d found before were either all-crypto or all-stocks, and I wasn’t sure which I wanted to focus on yet. See the full breakdown of what’s included at each tier before you commit

What the Team Behind This Is Actually Like

After the first week, I started doing what any sensible person does after spending money somewhere new: I looked into who actually runs this. The platform is stockswithjosh on Whop, and the Stocks with Josh website has more background context if you want to dig in. They also have a YouTube channel where you can get a feel for the teaching style before committing anything. That’s something I genuinely recommend doing. Watch a few videos. See if the communication style clicks for you. What came through in the reviews I read, and what I noticed in the community, is that this isn’t a one-person operation. There’s Josh, there’s Money Mike (aka SpyLord), there’s someone referred to as Ms. Mary. One review specifically said Ms. Mary “is methodical in her approach to taking profit and capital preservation” and that she “really cares about her students’ success and goes above and beyond.” Another mentioned that Money Mike is “super knowledgeable, patient, and really passionate about helping others improve.” That’s not standard boilerplate. Those are descriptions of people with actual distinct teaching styles. As someone who came in nervous that I’d get lost or ignored, that detail mattered. The platform has been operating since 2024 and has over 7,500 store members across its products. The review average across the store sits at 4.84 out of 5 stars across 25 reviews, with zero one-, two-, or three-star ratings when I checked. Read what other newcomers are actually saying before you decide

The Cost Question (Because It’s a Real One)

Let me be direct about the pricing because I sat with this for a while. The SWJ Trader Tier is **$60 per week**, which works out to roughly $240 a month if you’re doing the math. The Chart Goat U program comes in at $100 per month. Those are the numbers as of when I signed up. They could change. For someone who has never spent a cent on trading education, $100/month for Chart Goat U felt like the more approachable starting point. The framing in the product description is explicitly aimed at beginners, and the member count of 98 suggests a more intimate learning environment compared to the larger Trader Tier community. The Trader Tier at $60/week is clearly aimed at people who are more active, want live sessions weekly, and want faster access to chart analysis. If you’re still in “what is a candlestick” territory (which is where I started), Chart Goat U probably makes more sense as an on-ramp. If you’re ready to get more hands-on faster, the Trader Tier has the engagement level to back that up. The reviews for the Trader Tier average 4.90 stars across 20 ratings, with 18 five-star reviews. That’s the kind of number that’s hard to ignore. One more thing: when I first visited the Whop page, there was a welcome discount prompt. I don’t know if that’s always there or was specific to my visit, but it’s worth checking when you go. Those kinds of offers tend to be temporary. CHECK THE CURRENT PRICING and see if the welcome discount is still active

What Clicked, What Tripped Me Up

What actually worked for me:
  • The multi-instructor approach. Having different people covering different angles meant I wasn’t stuck if one explanation didn’t land. Money Mike’s style clicked for me fast. Other people in reviews mentioned Ms. Mary specifically. Having options matters.
  • Community access. The Discord component of the Trader Tier made me feel less alone in my confusion. Trading can feel isolating when you don’t know anyone else doing it.
  • Chart requests. Getting analysis on actual tickers I was watching instead of theoretical examples was the thing that made abstract concepts feel concrete.
  • The focus on education over just signals. One review put it plainly: “He and his team will teach you… not just point you in the right direction.” That’s the difference between dependency and actually building a skill.
What took adjustment:
  • The jargon density early on. You’ll want to keep a tab open with a basic trading glossary for the first week. I kept running into “key levels,” “support and resistance,” and “price action” and had to look those up separately before they started to feel natural.
  • The weekly billing on the Trader Tier felt like a faster financial commitment than I expected. Monthly felt more comfortable psychologically, even if the per-month math is similar over time.
  • There’s a real expectation that you put in the work. One review was clear about this: “How much you learn or how well you do is on us, the students. You will have to put in the time to watch, practice and do.” If you’re looking for a passive experience, that’s not what this is.

Who This Is Really For

Honestly, stocks with josh is built for people who are serious about actually learning to trade, not just following signals blindly. The Chart Goat U product explicitly calls out beginners who want hands-on guidance and simple strategies. If that’s you, it’s worth a serious look. It’s probably less suited for someone who wants fully automated trading with no learning curve. The emphasis here is education, understanding, and building judgment over time. If you’re someone who’s been saying “I want to learn trading” for months but never found the right starting point, this has the structure, the team depth, and the community to actually get you moving.

Where I Landed After A Few Weeks

Looking back at day one, when I had six tabs open trying to figure out what “key levels” meant, I can see how far the baseline has shifted. Not because I suddenly became some expert. But because the material met me where I was, even when I had embarrassingly basic questions. The thing that stuck with me most is what came up in multiple reviews: the team genuinely wants you to learn. That sounds like something a company would say about itself, but when it shows up repeatedly in verified buyer feedback from different people describing different instructors, it starts to feel true. The community around stockswithjosh is real, the instructors have distinct personalities and teaching approaches, and the structure is designed to actually build your skills. The over 7,500 members and near-perfect review average tell a consistent story. If you’ve been sitting on the fence about this, do what I did. Go look at the page, check the reviews from real buyers, see if there’s a welcome discount active when you visit. The information is all there. JOIN AND SEE WHAT YOUR FIRST SESSION LOOKS LIKE — this is where I started